More
Articles
by Gerald A. Honigman:
|
|
Unfortunately, we hear too much about suicide/homicide bombers in the
Middle East these days. And when Israel goes after the deliberate murderers
of its innocents, this then becomes the next excuse for Arabs to kill
more innocents.
The situation has become even more of a concern for Americans now that
our own officials state that it's just a matter of time before the United
States again becomes victimized this way. There is no doubt that this
is a horrendous human tragedy. But while Arabs and their supporters place
the blame for this on Israel, the truth is actually far more depressing.
Hundreds of millions of people became refugees in the course of the last
violent century (not to mention the millions before then). Many were displaced
between the two world wars. Scores of millions were uprooted in the 1947
partition of the Indian subcontinent into Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan.
Many more examples exist, like that involving Turks and Greeks; but one
truly stands out in light of the current turmoil in the Middle East: The
one half of Israel's five million Jews whose families fled Arab/Muslim
lands around the same time Arabs fled in the opposite direction because
of the invasion of Israel by five Arab states upon its rebirth in 1948.
This does not include another million of these Sephardim who fled to other
lands in the Diaspora, notably France and the Americas. Greater New York
City alone now has tens of thousands of Syrian Jews. They were known as
kelbi yahudi --"Jew Dogs"--in those Arab lands...So much for
so-called Arab tolerance of "their Jews" before the rise of
modern Zionism. How dare anyone else but Arabs demand a sliver of national
dignity in the region!
The Arabs had just rejected a plan (similar to the Indian partition) that
would have also created a second Arab state in historic Palestine. Jordan
had already emerged on 80% of original Mandatory Palestine issued to Britain
in the wake of the Paris Peace Conference on April 25, 1920. Colonial
Secretary Churchill had separated all of Palestine east of the Jordan
River and handed it over to Britain's Hashemite Arab allies in the creation
of Transjordan in 1922. Listen to Sabri Jiryis, a prominent Palestinian
Arab researcher at the Institute for Palestinian Studies in Beirut:
"While it is estimated that 700,000 Arabs fled the 1948 war...against
this...Arabs caused the expulsion of just as many Jews from Arab states...whose
properties were taken over...a population and property exchange occurred
and each side must bear the consequences (Al-Nahar, Beirut, 5/15/75)."
Much more evidence for this exists in books written by Arab kings and
officials as well as by others.
So, why is it that over fifty years later, Arabs-- who have received billions
of dollars in aid from the U.N., oil revenues, other international funds,
etc.--still have not relieved the plight of their own refugees? They have,
after all, twenty-two states on some six million square miles of territory--lands
that belonged mostly to non-Arab peoples like Kurds, Black Africans, Copts,
Berbers, etc. before their conquests and forced arabization in the name
of the Arab nation. Jews absorbed their refugees into their sole, tiny
state that is not even the size of New Jersey.
The answer can be illustrated by Arab actions. Some years back, with the
status of the territories unresolved, Israel offered to knock down the
dilapidated camps and replace them with new housing and better living
conditions. It's worth remembering that Egypt and Jordan occupied these
territories from 1948-1967 and not only did nothing about this but never
discussed the creation of another Palestinian Arab state here either.
The Arabs demanded that Israel do nothing to remedy life in the camps.
Again, why?
Quite simply, Arabs have used their own refugees as pawns in their war
to delegitimize Israel. For them, there is no justice nor suffering besides
their own. They don't want the refugee problem solved--not as long as
it means that a viable Israel will still exist on the morrow. That's why
they tacked on the "right of return" of millions of real or
alleged Arab refugees to the recent Saudi peace plan. The result is that
that Saudi "peace" plan still envisions Israel's Jews being
overwhelmed so that a second Arab state will replace Israel, not live
side by side with it. This should come as no shock since all Palestinian
(and many other) Arab maps, school books, etc. omit Israel as well. This
is also why current talk about a "provisional Palestinian Arab State"
being created at this time is scary. Faisal Husseini, the late showcase
moderate of the PLO, said that while he'd accept any land diplomacy would
yield, a purely Arab Palestine from the River to the Sea was the real
goal...the same old "destruction of Israel in stages" strategy
dominant since after the "one fell swoop" alternative collapsed
as a result of its failure in the Six Day War in 1967.
So, this tragic conflict still has no end in sight. And the horrendous
human tragedy specifically associated with suicide/homicide bombings has
been both created and sustained by Arabs themselves. Reasonable compromises
have been repeatedly offered--and rejected-- to end the Arab-Israeli conflict...certainly
more than anything Arabs have ever offered to the numerous native, non-Arab
peoples they conquered and forcibly arabized in carving out most of the
twenty-two states they now call their own.
|
|